2023: Jared Schmidt, Ski Cross – 2022 Olympian
2022: Tyrone Henry, Para Ice Hockey – two-time Paralympian in 2018, 2022, two silver medals
2021: Mason McTavish, Hockey – 2022 Olympian
2020: no winner selected (COVID-19 Pandemic)
2019: Tim Nedow, Athletics (shotput) – two-time Olympian in 2016, 2021
2018: Mike Woods, Cycling – two-time Olympian in 2016, 2021
2017: Vincent De Haitre, Speed Skating – three-time Olympian in 2014, 2018, 2021
2016: Vincent De Haitre, Speed Skating – three-time Olympian in 2014, 2018, 2021
2015: Dustin Cook, Alpine Skiing – 2018 Olympian
2014: Vincent De Haitre, Speed Skating – three-time Olympian in 2014, 2018, 2021
2013: Phil Scrubb, Basketball
2012: Craig Savill, Curling
2011: Tyson Hinz, Basketball
2010: Brad Sinopoli, Football
2009: Ian Mortimer, Sprint Canoe
2008: Rhys Hill and Angus Mortimer, Kayak
2007: Craig Savill, Curling
2006: Osvaldo Jeanty, Basketball
2005: Jeff Bean, Freestyle Skiing
2004: Jason Dunkerley, Athletics – four-time Paralympian in 2000, 2004, 2008, 2012, three silver medals, bronze medals
2003: Corey Locke, Hockey
Prior to 2003 there was just one Athlete of the Year selected. The history of those awards is available here.