2023: Scott Faithfull, Swimming
2022: Glenroy Gilbert, Athletics
2021: Glenroy Gilbert, Athletics
2020: no winner selected (COVID-19 Pandemic)
2019: Martin Dagenais, Hockey
2018: Steve Johnson, Soccer
2017: Taffe Charles, Basketball
2016: Glenroy Gilbert, Athletics
2015: Glenroy Gilbert, Athletics
2014: James Derouin, Basketball
2013: Glenroy Gilbert, Athletics
2012: Dave Smart, Basketball
2011: Dave Smart, Basketball
2010: Jimmy Zito, Soccer
2009: Andy McInnis, Athletics
2008: Andy McInnis, Athletics
2007: Dave Smart, Basketball
2006: Dave Smart, Basketball
2005: Dave Smart, Basketball
2004: Mike Crepin, Baseball
2003: Dave Smart, Basketball